The Thief on the Cross: Saving Faith and Repentance

The thief on the cross shows us both the freeness of salvation and the evidence of saving faith. In Luke 23:35–41, one criminal joins the mockery of Jesus while the other fears God, admits his guilt, and defends Christ’s innocence. He has no lifetime of good works to offer, yet his changed words reveal a changed heart. His story directs guilty sinners to the kindness and mercy of the crucified Savior.

Podcast: Play in new window | Download

Follow the podcast: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Amazon Music | RSS

Why People Mocked Jesus on the Cross

The crucifixion involved more than physical agony. Jesus also endured contempt, ridicule, and rejection. Scripture takes the harm done by words seriously: Proverbs 12:18 compares reckless speech to sword thrusts, and James 3 describes the tongue’s destructive power. The insults at the cross were part of His suffering.

Luke records the rulers challenging Jesus to save Himself, the soldiers mocking His kingship, and one criminal demanding that He rescue them. Each challenge treats escape from suffering as the test of His identity. If He is truly the Christ, they reason, He should come down from the cross.

The soldiers also offer Him sour wine amid their mockery. Luke tells us what they do, but does not describe them dangling it beyond His reach. The cruelty that is recorded is plain enough. They treat the suffering King as an object of scorn.

These demands echo earlier challenges for Jesus to prove Himself through a sign, such as those in Matthew 12:38 and 16:1. The mocking of Jesus reveals people setting their own conditions for recognizing Him, even as He accomplishes the salvation they need.

Jesus Remained on the Cross to Save Sinners

The mockers misunderstand His mission. Jesus came to give His life for sinners. Escaping the cross would not have completed that work. By remaining there, He obeyed the Father and offered the sacrifice through which His people are redeemed.

His suffering was willing. The One who had healed the sick and raised the dead was not overcome by a lack of power. He endured the cross in obedience and love. What His enemies interpreted as helplessness was the costly fulfillment of His saving purpose.

Even the ridicule belongs to the biblical picture of the suffering Messiah. Isaiah 53 describes the rejected servant bearing the sins of others. Psalm 22 portrays the righteous sufferer being mocked by people who challenge his trust in God. The contempt directed at Jesus fits the Scriptures His death fulfills.

The Crucified Jesus Is Still the King

Luke 23:38 draws attention to the inscription identifying Jesus as the King of the Jews. Surrounded by ridicule, His royal identity remains true. Human rejection cannot make Him less than the King God has sent.

The cross overturns the expectation that a king’s greatness must be displayed through immediate self-preservation. Jesus accomplishes His victory by giving Himself for His people. The question is whether we will receive the King who saves through suffering or demand a savior who simply serves our preferences.

Two Criminals Respond Differently to Jesus

Both criminals face death beside the same Savior. One insults Jesus and demands rescue. His recorded words contain no confession of guilt or acknowledgment of Christ’s innocence. The other rebukes him and speaks with a strikingly different concern: they are about to answer to God.

The second criminal acknowledges that their punishment is deserved and that Jesus has done nothing wrong. In the following verses, he asks Jesus to remember him in His kingdom and receives the promise of paradise (Luke 23:42–43). His hope rests in the King dying beside him.

For a fuller comparison of the men and Christ’s promise, see the two thieves on the cross and their two responses. Here, notice especially what the repentant man’s words teach us about saving faith.

What Evidence of Saving Faith Did the Thief Show?

The thief is a beautiful example of salvation by grace. He cannot undo his past, perform years of service, or offer a record of obedience as payment for forgiveness. Ephesians 2:8–9, Titus 3:5, and Romans 3:28 teach that salvation is God’s gift, received through faith rather than earned by works.

Yet the absence of merit is not the absence of change. James 2 warns against a profession of faith that remains dead and fruitless. The thief’s response already displays a new direction:

• He fears God rather than treating death as merely a loss of earthly comfort.
• He admits his guilt and accepts responsibility without making excuses.
• He stops participating in the mockery and rebukes it.
• He acknowledges Jesus’ innocence.
• He turns to Jesus as King and asks for mercy.

These responses do not purchase salvation. They show the reality of the faith by which he receives Christ. Ephesians 2:10 places good works after the gift of salvation as part of the life God prepares for His people. The thief has very little time left, but what he does with it matters.

His example comforts the person who fears it is too late to come to Christ. It also challenges the person who claims that faith can remain entirely indifferent to sin. Grace forgives guilty people and begins changing them.

Did Both Thieves Mock Jesus Before One Repented?

Matthew 27:44 and Mark 15:32 describe the criminals reviling Jesus, while Luke records one defending Him. Read together, the accounts show a change: a man who had shared in the insults turns from them and seeks Christ’s mercy.

The Gospel writers do not need to repeat every moment of the same event to agree. Matthew and Mark record the mockery; Luke gives us the later exchange that reveals repentance and faith. The contrast makes the grace shown to this man all the more striking.

God’s Kindness Calls Us to Repentance

What brought about this change? Luke does not tell us the precise moment or identify a particular statement as its cause. Jesus’ prayer, “Father, forgive them,” displays the mercy surrounding this scene. The thief may have heard it, but we should not present that possibility as a detail Luke explicitly supplies.

What Scripture does plainly teach is that God’s kindness is meant to lead us to repentance (Romans 2:4). His patience gives sinners reason to return to Him. It must never become an excuse to continue in sin; the following verse warns against a hard and unrepentant heart.

The thief’s story and Paul’s teaching belong together without requiring us to reconstruct an unrecorded conversion experience. At the cross we see a merciful Savior receiving a guilty man. In Romans we learn how to respond to divine kindness: with repentance, not presumption. For further reflection, consider this discussion of repentance.

Why Kindness Gives Guilty People Hope

Shame can make us want to hide. We may assume that our past is too ugly or our repeated failures too numerous for God to receive us. His kindness does not tell us our sins are small. It tells us there is mercy for sinners who come to Him.

The prodigal son illustrates this hope. Remembering that even his father’s hired servants have food, he resolves to return and confess his sin (Luke 15:17–19). His need and his remembrance of his father’s provision move him toward home. He does not repair his entire history before beginning the journey.

Likewise, understanding what leads us to repentance means holding guilt and grace together. We confess real wrongdoing because we trust a real Savior. God’s kindness encourages honest confession rather than hiding, minimizing, or defending our sin.

Confess Your Sin and Look to Christ

Luke’s account continues with the extraordinary events surrounding Jesus’ death. Before those events, this criminal has already turned to the crucified King. His confidence rests on Jesus, not on an opportunity to build a better record for himself.

The same Savior calls us to come. Fear God, confess your guilt, and stop treating His patience as permission to delay. Then look beyond your failures to Christ’s sufficient sacrifice and mercy.

Saving faith does not boast in what it can offer God. It receives what Christ has done, and its reality begins to appear in a changed response to Him. The thief on the cross had little time left, but he found the Savior he needed.

Questions for Reflection

• How do the thief’s words show repentance without becoming the basis of his salvation?
• Are you using God’s patience as a reason to return to Him or a reason to delay?
• How can you acknowledge your sin honestly while placing your hope in Christ’s mercy?

Watch the Sermon